Short answer: most homeowners pay between $150 and $400 for garage door spring replacement. The exact number depends on a few things. Here’s the breakdown.
What drives the price
Two spring types exist. Torsion springs mount on a bar above the door. Extension springs run along the tracks on each side.
Torsion springs cost more to replace. They need special tools and more skill to install safely. Extension springs are simpler, and usually cheaper.
Door size matters too. A single-car door needs less spring than a double-car door. Bigger door, bigger spring, bigger bill.
Should you replace one spring or both?
If you have two torsion springs and one breaks, replace both. I know that sounds like a sales pitch. It isn’t.
Springs wear out on a similar timeline. If one snapped from age, the other is close behind. A second service call in a few months costs more than doing both now.
Typical price ranges
- Single torsion spring: $200-$400
- Both torsion springs: $250-$500
- Extension springs (pair): $150-$300
- Emergency or after-hours service: add $75-$150
These are typical ranges, not quotes. Get an actual estimate before anyone touches your door.
Signs you need this before it becomes an emergency
A spring rarely fails without warning. Watch for a loud bang from the garage (that’s often the spring going), a door that feels heavier than usual, a visible gap in the spring coil, or a door that won’t stay open on its own.
Catch it early and you skip the Saturday morning where your car’s stuck in the garage.
How often should garage doors be serviced?
Once a year for most homes. Twice a year if you use the garage door multiple times a day. A yearly check catches wear before it turns into a snapped spring.
Is DIY worth it?
No. Garage door springs hold a lot of tension. People have been seriously hurt trying to replace them without the right tools. This is one repair where paying a professional isn’t optional. It’s just safety.
If you’re dealing with a broken spring in Indianapolis, local technicians can usually get to you the same day.